This is usually caused by a timezone issue. If you change your Xero timezone settings to match your Recurly timezone, this will not happen.
To change your Xero timezone:
- Go to Accounting
- Select Advanced
- Click on Financial Settings
- Scroll down to the Timezone drop down menu and select a Timezone.
You can also go directly to the following link: https://go.xero.com/Setup/FinancialSettings.aspx